Strategy

The Imperative of Perpetual Vision

"Visioneering is a clear mental picture of what could be, fueled by the conviction that it should be.” -Andy Stanley

So often organizations jump into strategy and tactics before planning and the results are chaos, confusion or disaster...or all three.  But even those organizations that understand this oftentimes begin planning before they have developed "a clear mental picture of what could be."  This clear mental picture of what could be is best pursued through a process of "possibility discovery"... or as Stanley calls it, "Visioneering."

As human beings we quite naturally develop strong paradigms of thinking and action over time.  This process begins at birth and everyone has a paradigm.  A Paradigm is "a fundamental unquestioned set of assumptions that determines our worldview." These assumptions (aka biases) are formed by our past experiences (good and bad), our environment, socioeconomic influences and many other factors. Paradigms act as filters.  We quite literally see the world through our paradigm filters. These filters can severely limit our ability to see beyond what we know and what we believe to be true.  People in leadership positions are no more or no less susceptible to these paradigms, however, in their role as leaders, they have a far greater responsibility to be aware of and understand the effect of what is commonly referred to as "paradigm blindness." Following are some notable examples of (at least initial) paradigm blindness:  

“I think there’s a world market for about five computers.” —Thomas Watson, Chairman of IBM, 1943.  

“There is no reason for any individual to have a computer in their home.” —Ken Olson, President of Digital Equipment Corporation, 1977.

"Who the hell wants to hear actors talk?” —Harry Warner, Warner Brothers
Pictures, 1927.  

“There is no likelihood that man can ever tap the power of the atom.” —Robert Milliken, Nobel Prize winner in physics, 1920.  

There are literally hundreds of other examples of paradigm blindness that can be found by a Google search, but the bottom line is this...our paradigms stand in the way of us seeing the possibilities in front of us...if we let them.

Organizations cannot reach their full potential if leaders don't recognize this effect and take steps to insure that their vision is expanded as widely as possible and every effort is made to pursue the discovery of possibilities and limit predetermined limitations!  This is not a one time activity (aka static Vision Statement), but rather the development of a purposeful and perpetual "visioneering" discipline.  In today's world, organizations that don't have this discipline, no matter the industry, are doomed to stall, or fail. 

For this kind of corporate discipline to develop, first and foremost, it must start at the top.  Leaders must discover their unique paradigm, how this paradigm interacts with other decision-makers and how it impacts productivity (or lack thereof) across the organization. Leaders must learn how to broaden their thinking and expand their vision.  However, it is virtually impossible for leaders to "see" their own paradigm and how this effects their decisions and their intention toward others without going through a formal process of discovery. There are tools and techniques specifically designed to aid in this discovery process.

Case in point #1 - I was hired by a Board of Directors several years ago to turn around (aka rescue) a failing software start-up company where they collectively had a great deal of money invested. The young founders were bright, talented and hard-working. Their technology was sound and their business plan was adequate. However, for a variety of reasons they had lost their way and were floundering to identify their vision and mission. Revenues were falling fast. After a few facilitated discovery sessions, a sequestered weekend away (no cell phones) and some strategy changes, the company was back on track and was acquired for considerable money a few months later. In one of the discovery sessions I found a half-baked software product that, with a few tweaks and enhancements, was very valuable to a specific industry at the time. Ironically, that software had been put on the shelf by the CEO 6 months earlier and considered unimportant.

Case in point #2 - I have had the privilege of working with prospective entrepreneurs and small business (SME) owners in Morocco, Afghanistan, Libya & China, along with Native Americans here in the States. In all but a few rare cases a pattern has emerged in persistent, generational poverty caused by a lack of economic prosperity.  This pattern is a combination of deep seated paradigm blindness entrenched in history and the corresponding lack of ability to imagine and grasp possibilities. Until these paradigms are discovered and addressed, progress simply cannot be made. you have to look no further than our well documented nation building failures in Afghanistan for proof.  I can go on and on about this.

Perpetual vision (aka visioneering) is a learned, not an innate, skill. It is, however, one of the most valuable skills an organization's leader can have. No matter the industry or the business, the discipline of perpetual vision is imperative for sustained success.  As previously stated, there are tools and techniques to examine these, evaluate their impact, and leverage them to the advantage of an individual and an organization.

Tribal Economic Development Elements

 

(Posting to LinkedIn Tribal Economic Development Group)

Please allow me to introduce myself.  I am new to this Tribal Economic Development Group and I have enjoyed reading each of the comments and perspectives on this subject posted by others. I am a business strategist and serial entrepreneur with 9 companies under my belt (1 NASDAQ IPO) and a successful business consultancy spanning 4 different countries. Following are some of my own thoughts on this important topic:

1- Gaming - is an awesome profit generator that should be leveraged to the max, but it WILL decline at some rate TBD over the next 10-15 yrs. Gaming should therefore be considered "a bridge to diversification and sustainability." The length of the "bridge" depends on many factors. Don't be surprised like Atlantic City!  Now is the time for tribes to plan and act on business diversification.

2- Planning - each tribe is different so strategic economic planning is absolutely critical path. "If you fail to plan you plan to fail." Every tribe can benefit significantly from an outside perspective here. Tribal insiders oftentimes have limited and/or politically impacted viewpoints.  Not bad, but simply a fact.

3- Leadership - developing transformational leaders must be a high priority for every tribe. There is simply no substitute for "transformational" leadership. Most traditional leadership training is ineffective. “Only three things happen naturally in organizations: friction, confusion & under-performance.  Everything else requires leadership.” -Peter Drucker.  Nations, tribes, governments and companies rise and fall on leadership.

4- Entrepreneurship - every tribe should have a formal business development plan that includes small business incubation and acceleration.  I am a member of the NBIA(.org) and there are plenty of resources available. You simply cannot ignore the stimulation of organic business growth inside the tribe.

5- Operational Effectiveness - to be fully effective, business & economic development must be separated from tribal government. They are simply totally different “engines” for the tribe. I know of a billion dollar tribe that is stifled completely by the unyielding mix of these two together, so their tribe is only realizing a tiny fraction of their awesome potential.

6- Economic Development - means effectively exploiting your (many) tribal advantages and meeting your tribal people where they are. I know of a tribe whose annual revenue is $850K/year, but their people are living in abject poverty.

7- Possibilities - following are some things I believe every tribe should carefully consider and evaluate:

a- The leverage to the max of ALL natural resources.  Obvious, but often overlooked with respect to possibilities.

b- Agri-business (Farm-to-Table/Product)(full value chain)(greenhouses, aqua/hydroponics, etc.).  There are also great opportunities in Agri-Tourism. Tribes must leverage their agrarian roots in some form with modern technology and all available other advantages.

c- Genuine, culturally sensitive and relevant tourism. Why do I know that this is likely underdeveloped? The largest and most influential tourism consultancy in the country, perhaps the world, had never worked with a Tribal Nation before I hired them for a project a year ago.

d- Highway Retail (Travel Plazas, Truck Stops, C-Stores). Yes, there are a lot of tribes that own and run these however, are they producing 12-18% EBITDA? This is possible under the right conditions & structure. I am aware of a tribe with a C-Store generating $12M+ revenue annually and losing $200K in the same time period.  This is a tragedy and easily fixed.

e- Artrepreneurship.  Tribal artists in every discipline should be increasingly successful as entrepreneurs and there are sophisticated ways to help them be so. I work with a company in Dallas that literally built an entire art community with local artists using technology and advanced retail strategies. One single location has 7,000 pieces of art from 140 different artists.

f- Federal “Promise Zone”-The US Government has a brand new program (USDA administered) to provide unprecedented economic development dollars to tribal nations (and other under-served areas) and the 2nd round RFP comes out in August of this year.  The Choctaw Nation is currently the only Tribal Nation in the country with this designation.

I can go on and on about leveraging EB5, FTZs, NMTCs, CDFI, IEC, IIP, SBA Loans, Crowd-Funding, etc., but in the interest of brevity, I will stop here.  Bottom line...tribal nations have lots of opportunity and I am very bullish on their (your) futures.